I just discovered Buffalo Exchange about two months ago, but I have had nothing but great experiences! I went in to sell some old clothes that I'd outgrown, and since I was a first timer, the super sweet buyer explained their system to me. If they decide to buy something from you, they mark it with a price right away. You either get 50% of their sell price in store credit or 30% in cash. Not too shabby! She also explained that certain brands (like from Target or Old Navy), they don't usually buy because the store trends change so often. Makes sense and seems pretty reasonable to me. Their inventory constantly changes and since they buy from random people, their selection is always random. I have found some great deals here, you may just have to spend some time looking for them!
Pros: Ever-changing selection
Cons: Parking is a pain
more