While I believe The Paper Mill has a really great selection, I believe the owner is very snotty and NEVER friendly.  I order invitations from her due to convenience and I don't believe she has ever smiled at me much less looked at me.  She comes across smug and just unlikable.  With a great store, you would think there would be great service but unfortunately there isn't.  If you don't mind ""ugly"" owners that don't help at all, but a good selection then this is your place.
                        
more