I'm not sure why others have had a terrible experience here, but I've been ten times or more and have been highly impressed each time! (It's possible that the other reviews are people representing OTHER Indian restaurants and are threatened by India Star's quality) I agree that their former location was a bit of a dive, but they're now located on Douglas Ave and have expanded and updated. If you're a person who judges a restaurant solely on ambience, Tandoor is the right choice. However, if you prefer to judge a restaurant on the quality of their FOOD, India Star is the appropriate choice. Their staff is nice, and prompt. In fact, my boyfriend mentioned he liked the music that was playing, and the next time we came in the chef had burned the CD for him!
Pros: The food, the service, the prices
Cons: It's not the suburban cookie-cutter restaurant, if you like that sort of thing
more