I took my husband here last week for a romantic dinner, and it was perfect.  I made a 5:30 reservation.  When we arrived the place was empty except for 2 people at the bar, and we were seated at the only window seat, which was absolutely great.  We had plenty of attention since we were the only ones there for a little while so we looked through all our options and asked many questions.  We like having a variety of food and we like to share, so our server helped us pick our dinner and made a great wine suggestion based on our tastes.  I chose the 4-course menu and my husband added an appetizer and an entree.  We started with cocktails and the calamari and my appetizer (can't remember exactly - it was chicken on a crispy bread).  We wanted muscles but they were out. I don't remember my cocktail and honestly I'd go without it next time.  The calamari was okay but nothing great in my opinion - the batter did not have much crispiness to it and the aioli and vinegar were good but... eh.  The appetizer with my 4-course was awesome, though. I didn't really want to share with him :) We split my pesto gnocchi which was also moderately good (but we devoured). Then we received our entrees - he had chicken on a bed of cheesy polenta, and I had cod on a bed of potatoes.  They were amazing.  We like to eat out and my husband said he had had plenty of good dinners but this was the best he'd had in a long time.  I have never heard him moan over his food like that! The combo of chicken and polenta was truly fantastic.  I liked my cod but my potatoes were the best.  We literally cleaned our plates.  And then we finished with banana bread pudding (SO good) with a side of chocolate gelato.
We must've been there for two hours and after a while the place filled up.  We loved our seat and realized it's good to get there early.  Overall it felt very romatic - we had a great time and thoroughly enjoyed our meal. We will be coming back soon, and we will be bringing friends and family.
Pros:  Amazing fresh,local cuisine; service; parking; changing menu
Cons:  Some cocktails... not much else
                        
more