I have been to the Cellar 4 or 5 time over a 6 year period, recently during New Years weekend, and everytime I have gone, the experience has been better. All the comedians are good to great, many of which I have gone on to see on TV/Film/etc. Service has always been on par and I have never had an issue with any of the club staff. And on my latest trip, Dave Chapelle gave us a nice 15 minute set. I love this place and plan on going back each time I visit NY.
Pros: Everything
Cons: Cramped Seating...but you forget as soon as the show starts
more