I have to admit ive been reading reviews for a couple of weeks and they have all been amazing to say the least. So today i finally found time with my schedule to make a trip i live in manalapan on rt 33 so it was about a half an hour trip for me not bad but when i got there i have to admit i wasnt all that wowed and im not saying it was bad it was good but not amazing not compared to Totonnos or grimaldis in brooklyn or lombardis in manhattan maybe it was the lack of a real coal burning oven or maybe it was because the crust was just too burnt to the point where it was black or maybe it was that the crust was just to thin i got a large sausage and a small clam with tomato first of all the sausage pie was cut in very weird shapes not the usual 8 slice setup but more of like strips with some resembling pizza slices and others just long thin rectangulars i dont know if this was an off night as i have read that the hudson location was known for being rather inconsistent but i guess will have to give it another try and also try the hamilton location for some comparison
Pros: parking pizza was good
Cons: service ambience no restroom pizza shaped weird hard to share
more