We had our concerns about Mesa Grill but they came through big time. The food was very good (but heavy). I had the veal and my wife fish. The fish was borderline over cooked but the flavor on both was great. The tamale appetizer very good and the dessert (flan - not exactly) was as well. Ask to sit in Encina's section..she and the buss boy provided excellent service.
Pros: Good food. Good Service (but might depend who your server is)
Cons: Pretty heavy (butter, sauces, etc), might be too noisy for some
more