This place was recommended by the concierge at Holiday Inn Select Oakland when I interviewed for a position at the University of Pittsburgh. My wife and I have been there regularly over the past 4 years and have recommended it to out of towners. Never a problem. Not cheap. But not exorbitant either (better food for the buck than Mortons). One of the best spanish red wine I have had (rioja - Muga). There are a zillion specials - everything from Octopus to suckling pig - but waiter will repeat as many times as you want, and their suggestions are good, just tell them what kind of food you generally like or dont like.
Pros: food, ambiance, service
Cons: would not take kids there
more