I've lived in this city my entire adult life and I just discovered Gatsby's a little over two years ago. I wish I had found it earlier! This place is awesome. They have great food (try the cobb salad or chicken club panini), friendly speedy service, an awesome DJ on the weekends and nice atmosphere on the weekdays (especially if you're a sports fan). The crowd there is a little more down to earth than your typical SoHo snotheads. I don't know why girls gone wild hasn't discovered this place yet, but Gatsby's seems to be always packed with attractive women looking to tear it up for an evening. You can hardly walk through the place with out being purposefully chatted up by some intoxicated co-ed or visiting business woman. I now go there to cap off almost every night out on the town. Absolutely the best.
Pros: Great Bartenders, great food, fun crowd.
Cons: Not the cheapest bar in the world, but what do you expect in SoHo.
more