My wife took me to Cinelli's for the first time for my birthday a few years ago. We have been there many many times since and have thoroughly enjoyed it every time. The food is authentic Italian and superb. (As a relocated yankee via NJ and Pgh. - I can assure you its great.) The specials are creative and always exceptional. Plus if you can't find something you like, just ask and the chef will do something special for you.
However, the best part of Cinelli's is the personal service. The first time you go, you will be treated cordially but with a smile. By the third or fourth time you go, you are family. From the hostess to the service staff, everyone stops by to say "Hi, how are ya?" and will make time to chat (if they aren't too busy). The wait staff and bartenders are always attentive and make a point of getting to know you. On weekends, they typically have live entertainment (including a Sinatra-like crooner) that is a nice break from Muzak. We have become so comfortable at Cinelli's that at this point, we don't even look at a wine list. We ask Glen for a recommendation. He always brings a few bottles over and describes each in detail and offers his favorite of the bunch. Never gone wrong yet. In contrast to all the chain restaurants that are homogenizing our food choices, this is a special place.
In short, its like the verse from the "Cheers" theme... "Where everyone knows your name..."
Pros: Food and personal service
Cons: Gets busy at times - make a reservation.
more