I would recommend this place mostly for the great view. Ask for an outdoor table in warmer days. The food has been consistently good but not as innovative as many other restaurants in the city. The decor could use some upgrading. I have more modern tastes in interior design and I can see the potential for this space if you use minimalist furniture. The faux Victorian (I'm not sure what it is) style they are trying to achieve makes the place look aged. Their waitstaff needs more polishing but in general they are courteous. They also have a sommelier who was very helpful in recommending wines and was not at all pushy in making us order the expensive bottle. Yes, I suppose, you can call it ""touristy"" as more people get wind of this place, but that's not always a bad thing. It is also very pricey but I think it's worth a try. The boat ride to and from the restaurant is just breathtaking it makes you feel glad you live in New York so why not share the joys of brilliantly-lit skyscrapers to others?
Pros: Good food and great view.
Cons: Pricey. Decor borders on tacky.
more