The "scene" description is pretty accurate and honestly and I can't believe why this place is on of the best-of lists... makes me question the list! Reading these reviews, I notice a common thread - there are many infuriated, unsatisfied reviewers and then multiple, nice-sounding happy-go-lucky patrons... seems like there may be some fabricated reviews - As for my own personal experience, my office had a after work party there on a tuesday not to long ago and the drinks and service were very blah. the food sounded like regular bar appetizer grub but came out HORRIFIC! In general, the place doesn't feel like NY - it feels like a random pub in mid-america, which might appeal to some, but for the location and price - there are way better options nearby!
Pros: You can walk by better places nearby and see what you're missing
Cons: It's like a lame horse waiting to be taken out of commision!
more