A group of us have been going to the Comedy Cellar since the 90's and it's always a good night. The website is key to find out who will be performing that week as well. Before the show, either get the great Armenian / Lebanese food next door or get drinks at Minetta's Tavern. The history in that bar is awesome, including the final scene in Sleepers.
Pros: Awesome comics, proximity to the comic, reservations
more