Talbots has been around for over 50 years because it's awesome. It has four distinct sections -toys, hobbies, bikes and baby department. Each is pretty well stocked, and you always find fun and unique things there. There is also sections just for train and doll collectors. I'm all grown up, and I still like to take a walk through it when I'm having a bad day!!
PROS: friendly people work there, some of them for decades!
CONS: sometimes hard to find parking, it's in the middle of downtown
more