There is nothing lacking from this establishment other than the stuffiness that comes with an established name in the market. The staff are very attentive, the wine list is extraordinary (allowing for all wallet sizes from the 30$ to the 2000$ bottle), the sides are great and can serve a small party, the steaks...oh the steaks!
Thier sommelier is knowledgeable, as are the waitors. The bar is a great ""networking"" location. The decor is a modern take on the traditional steakhouse. Rothmann's is pleasing in every aspect!
As a side note, just down the block you can find (since NY is a non-smoking city anymore) a Davidoff of Geneva to get your after dinner smoke (which you might want to do early before they close). It is just off of 5th Ave.
Pros: extensive wine list, smart/attentive staff, location
more