Carmine's is probably one of those love it or hate it places. I find it to be a very good example of a restaurant that doesn't pretend to be something it's not. There are certainly much worse places to eat "great" Italian food in the Midtown area.
The food is great. You will see many items you are familiar with like lasagna, ravioli, and manicotti. The sauces are very rich and delicious. As many people state, the portions are amazingly huge. Two entrees for a party of four is plenty. The selection is large.
The atmosphere is so-so. It's a massive, open room with closely-packed tables. It can get quite loud during the dinner rush, but not annoyingly so. It's not a great place for a romantic dinner, but families and groups of people out to have a good time will certainly find it enjoyable.
Pros: Rich, delicious sauce, Great selection, Familiar foods
Cons: Long waits after 6PM, Can be loud at times
more