I'm from New York so ofcourse I'm not going to think any pizza from California is good (and trust me I've gone to plenty of pizza joints in the Bay Area).
I tried Zackery's pizzeria in Rockridge about 5 years ago. I was pleasantly surprised by the taste. It was really good! The only thing I was surprised was the price. A ""pie"" of pizza was a lot more expensive than what I would pay for in New York City!
But if you are in the area and want a good pizza - you HAVE to go to Zachary's (regardless of the price).
Pros: near BART, good quality pizza
Cons: , limited parking, a bit overpriced
more