I haven't been to the original Coney Island location, but the Manhattan location is a joke. It's tasteless. Don't waste your time. Go to Patsy's on 117th and 1st or Johnny's in Mt. Vernon, NY. There are several pizza places which are resting on their laurels - Lombardi's, Grimaldi's and John's among them. But Totonno's has really lost it altogether. Of the classic places - places 60+ years old, only Patsy's and Sally's in New Haven, have really kept up the tradition. But to be fair, I still have to trek out the Coney Island.
Cons: Bland
more