Fanelli's has consistently delivered--their burger is unarguably the best in the entire city. Unbelievable! Amazing pesto sauce, crab cakes to dies for, etc. The prices are extremely reasonable. This place is such a legend and NY staple. I saw Claire Danes eating there awhile ago. It has a lot of appeal and although nothing fancy, it has it's own charm. Unpretentious and straight to the point! It's the second oldest restaurant in NYC, and you can see why it has lasted all this time. Can be quite busy.
Pros: FOOD, Prices, NYC Legend
Cons: crowded
more