I've been to Emmy's twice and had a great time both times. I think you go more for the ambience than the food.
My spaghetti was fine, but nothing to write home about. However, the DJ on Oct. 3 (a Friday night) was outstanding. She definitely helped set the mood for the evening.
Some of the other selections for food seemed odd. There were $12 fish and chips on the menu. $12 for fish and chips?
It's a fun, cute place with a huge wait. But I would wait again.
Pros: atmosphere, dim lighting
Cons: basic food, long wait
more