I have been going to Webster Hall for a about ten years, and I have never left before closing time! The music pumps and you can not leave the dance floor...whichever one you're on!
A former resiedent of long Island, I would make the trip to NYC about once a month to get my groove on. Now living in the dirrrrty South (Florida), I find myself really missing the Hall.
Pros: variety of music, atmosphere, great crowd
Cons: prices, line around the block
more