We arrived to a hostess area crowded by four hosts/ hostesses- complete overkill for a Monday night at a medium sized restaurant. The Caesar salad was the worst I've ever had. My pasta was overcooked and my boyfriend's steak tips were accompanied by incredibly dry and tasteless mashed potatoes. It took over 15 minutes for them to go back to the kitchen and cut a piece of key lime pie which was pretty pathetic considering the over abundance of staff. The decor of Not Your Average Joe's may look appealing from the street, however I urge you to reconsider your restaurant choice and perhaps try Stellina's (located right next to Joe's) or one of the other wonderful restaurants on Main Street.
Cons: Slow Service, Sub Par Food
more