The food is awesome, portions large, and the prices reasonable. I agree with the previous posting, that with the renovation it has lost some of the little neighborhood atmosphere. On my last visit we arrived around 9 on a Saturday, and although it wasn't crowded, the waitress acted like we were inconveniencing her, forgot bread, drinks, etc. One of the regular guy waiters picked up on it, and helped out. The parking guys outside were great, they even let us park the HD on the sidewalk in front.
Pros: Real NY Italian Food
Cons: Service Hit and Miss
more