Add my voice to the ""Mmmm, good pizza!"" side of the debate. The pepperoni was sweet/spicy and plentiful. The mix of cheese (not just mozzarella) was tasty too. Cosetta's also serves salads, sandwiches, and hot pasta dishes, always in huge portions. Serving is cafeteria style and there is seating both upstairs and down. Stroll the market to find just the right olive oil or that European chocolate that makes you drool. Tip for parents: find a table upstairs that overlooks the pizzamakers; it's fun to watch them before and during your meal.
Pros: Neighborhood feel, Fresh ingredients, Wonderful aroma
Cons: Parking, occasionally, First floor crowding
more