I love Toad Hall. Hard to say why, but it's one of those places I keep coming back to. It has a good atmosphere, a diverse set of people, no 'tude, a pool table, and a fair-to-good jukebox. Doesn't do food, but they provide a delivery menu, or you can pop next door to Lucky Strike.
Pros: Atmosphere, Lack of Pretension, Pool
Cons: Can get crowded, Can be empty
more