We went to the Stonewall Inn a month ago and the pizza was fantastic. The crust was perfect, it was busy but the service was good. We went again this weekend, not busy, took 30 minutes to get our pizza (we noticed the person at the counter kept leaving and going to the Stonewall Inn or somewhere... leaving customers standing at the front desk), and when we got our pizza it was not cooked all the way through. We were going to send it back but it took so long to get our food, and the counter girl was gone again, that we just left it. We may go back to give them another try... but was very disappointed in our last visit.
Pros: Could be good but not consistant
Cons: slow service