I can't help but compare Stevi B's to Cici's Pizza. After all, both are all-you-can-eat pizza buffet chains and both cost just $3.99 per adult. They both have loyalty cards. (The number of stamps you need for a free meal varies at each location.)
Better than Cici's:
Stevi B's is much cleaner than both of the Cici's in Tallahassee. The used plates were cleared off of
Stevi B's accepts credit cards.
Stevi B's has more "adventuresome" varieties of pizza. During our visit, we tried noodle pizza, taco pizza (nacho cheese, salsa, jalepenos, and tortilla chips) and a pizza with a toping that we think was thinly sliced potatoes.
More salad toppings, like green olives and pineapple.
The arcade has games that award tickets which can be redeemed for small toys.
There are more dessert choices.
Not as good as Cici's:
There are no pinball machines in the arcade!
You cannot take drinks (or food) into the arcade--That means that someone needs to wait outside of the arcade with your beverage cup, or you need to wait until the end of your meal to visit the arcade.
The pasta is not as plentiful or tasty.
There aren't as many different varieties of pizzas out at one time.