I love Essential Alternatives.  If I need a gift for someone, whether it is my mother, a friend, or my fiancee, this is my first(and usually only) stop.  Every room in my house has at least one item from here and there are still quite a few things I want.  Carol does a great job of mixing items from Vermont craftspeople with items from all over the world.  You'll find watercolors by local star Peter Huntoon, a huge selection of from simple studs to multi-strand pearl necklaces, tons of wall sculptures, unique picture frames, candles, and lots of ceramics.  This is also the only place I know to get a really nice jewelery box.  Even better, the inventory is always changing.  The prices are very reasonable, another reason this is my favorite gift store.
Pros:  Great Selection, Local crafts, Location, Prices
                        
more