I have been ordering from Eiselen's Pastry Shoppe for 30 years and I would highly recommend them. Everything is hand made on site and the taste and quality of their baked goods and cakes just doesn't exist anywhere else. My sister moved out to Colorado 10 years ago and she has Eiselen's cinnamon buns shipped to her house at least twice a year!
Pros: unbeatable taste, reasonable prices, specialty goods (just ask Rick, the owner)
Cons: there's only one location!