Went with a group from my office to have drinks at the upstairs bar.  We were there probably 3 hours, drinking and eating appetizers.  The service was decent, drinks came fast, good football game on, etc.  There was 8 of us, at most, there at one time.  When we got the tab, we put it on one credit card, it was $646, we tipped the bartender $125 on the card, and another $20 in cash.  She took this, and never told us that we had already been charged 18% gratuity on the check.  So she got a total of $236 for a tip.  We should have known to look, being a large group - but how rude and tacky could a place be?! \r	
My company just moved onto the block from 57th St, and we go out a lot as big groups and for corporate events.  Needless to say we won't be going there again.
Pros:  Lots of TV's, good for sports fans.
Cons:  Tourist Trap.  Add Gratuity to bills and don't tell people.  Stairs.
                        
more