Despite arriving on a slow Thursday night at 6:00pm, we had to wait to be seated. We were offered our choice of two tables, a 2-top or a 4-top. Since there was just the 2 of us, I chose the 2-top. The waitress seemed confused by this and asked us several more times if we wanted to switch tables. Weird.
The salad was very plain, just lettuce with a very runny Italian dressing. The bread was grocery store bread, with little pats of butter in plastic containers like at a diner.
I had the spaghetti with meat sauce and my wife had lobster ravioli. Both were just plain, without much taste. They didn't stand out in any way.
It was a BYOB place, and the other clientele were dressed in ripped t-shirts and dirty blue jeans. After we finished our meal, it took about seven minutes for some reason to receive our bill.
In my opinion, the food, service, atmosphere, and prices are much better at Bucca di Beppo.
Pros: Food was hot
Cons: Bland food, bland bread, odd service