My fiance and I went to Amici on a Sunday evening. We began with a decent glass of wine and a basket of rustic bread with oilve oil. The main dining room was modern and appealing, but at times felt like a cafeteria with its open floor and uniform rows of "4-top" tables. I started with a one-dimensional spinach and mixed greens salad with pecans and goat cheese. My fiance ordered the prosciutto-wrapped melon, which came on a salad plate, cut in long plain wedges, with the prosciutto slapped on top. No presentation, nothing special. We ordered 2 different snapper dishes and were surprised to find they arrived with little to no sides. His came with 3 spears of asparagus and mine with a sparse topping of tomatoes, garlic and crab in a thin "infused" tomato broth. I was a bit confused, wondering if there was a section of a la carte sides on the menu that I may have overlooked...until I spotted (to my horror) a round BUFFET-style table in the middle of the dining room with sides on it! I wouldn't find it an issue if the entrees weren't at the price point that they are. I also had no issue with the size of the portions either, but for what we were paying for the dinner, I didn't expect a buffet-style ANYTHING. My one rave would be the tiramisu. Rich, sweet, amazing. We did go back a second time to give it another try. My fiance ordered the lamb shank, which was very tender, but came with just a scoop of risotto. I ordered "handkerchief" pasta sheets, folded into pockets and stuffed with cheese and crab. Delicious as well, but came with nothing else. I can't deny that the food is good, but I'm still debating if it's good enough to warrant spending $300 for 2 people. I had very high expectations for this restaurant's food and service, but it wasn't what I'd call a good value for what we received.
Pros: Delicious food, nice atmosphere
Cons: Poor value, average service
more