For the best fish in town, Dirk's is the place. For the best meat, go to Paulina Market. Enough said.
Neither is cheap but the quality is unsurpassed - even by most restaurants in Chicago. If you want Jewel selection and prices, feel free to go there but I guarantee you're not getting the same thing. The only supermarket that can compare to Dirk's quality is Whole Foods but the prices are high there as well. You get what you pay for.
Pros: Fresh fish, Top quality, Great sauces, etc.
Cons: Expensive, Parking can be tough
more