Some of the user reviews on this site complain about the prices at Eli's. You know what? You get what you pay for. If you can't deal, go to the Food Emporium and stop complaining. I thought the prices at Eli's were perfectly fair and not much different from Citarella. Maybe marginally higher, but then I think Eli's is a nicer store than Citarella, so I'm not going to split hairs about it being a touch more expensive. The store, by the way, is incredibly spacious and relaxing to shop in. Everything they sell is superior quality. The only thing that didn't impress me was the fish. Decent, but nothing great. I guess with Rosedale's and Citarella right near by they figured why bother.
Pros: Top-notch quality, Huge selection, Spacious and relaxing
Cons: maybe a touch pricey, fish not spectacular
more