This store alone has more than most places I've visited although the quality lacks in some of the booths. Prices are a bit high because Stillwater is a tourist trap and they hike up the prices on items. Unless you know the going rate for a piece, i would advise not buying in Stillwater. Unless you don't mind paying a little more, go for it. There are some stores that have good prices, not all are expensive. You just have to look.
All of Stillwater is a antique trap and there are many stores to go through. Plan on spending a day in Stillwater and wear good walking shoes. Parking is hard to find later in the day.
Pros: large variety, many stores, decent finds
Cons: hard to find parking, can get crowded, can be expensive
more