Keystone Rare Coins Inc

4.1
22 reviews
Write review
id: 27691804
marker

3029 College Heights Blvd
Allentown, PA 18104

marker
(610) 770-9500
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Main categories:

Coin Dealer

Related categories:

Other

Reviews
( 17 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 5 )

Best

Very professional, fair and honest....would be the first place to go for knowledge of coins and stamps

Worst

My wife talked to the owner recently and had an agreed upon price prior to going to the shop. When she arrived the owner back-pedaled and tried to low ball her for their own perso...

Great prices on GOLD! 8/21/2013

Very good pricing on gold! Would recommend for anyone looking for a trustworthy dealer. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 4/8/2013

This place is hands down the best in the lehigh valley. I took my belongings to many different buyers and received nothing but horrid offers. Keystone pays the most. more
Reply | Report abuse |

keystone coins 4/13/2012

Rude and full of BS went there with graded coins by ngc and pcgs first guy was older and very nice and then a younger guy came over and he was very rude and cocky Had a 1903 $2.5 Ms 66 gold liberty and he said he had like 20 of them in his safe what BS there's only 48 of them in the world ms66 or better asked to see them told me he couldn't open safe come back another day don't know if this guy thought I was stupid and maybe he could get my coins dirt cheap or what but Northampton coin was very nice and took time to look in the book and make me offers that were very fair keystone don't even deserve 1 star more
Reply | Report abuse |

Amazing Prices! 2/8/2012

Keystone Rare Coins has amazing prices for gold and sterling jewelry! I sold my gold jewelry once before at another local coin shop in the valley. I thought I received a good price until I took my next pieces to Keystone Rare Coins. I saw their ad in the paper and read their reviews. Both are accurate! I received much more money at Keystone Rare Coins than I did at the other local coin shop. I brought in what seemed to be about the same amount and received almost $250 more at Keystone Rare Coins. Never go anywhere else! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Reputable Business! 2/3/2012

I was nervous to sell my gold jewelry. When I shopped around at local coin and jewelry stores in the Lehigh Valley, I found not only did Keystone Rare Coins pay me the highest prices, but they also made me feel extremely comfortable! Keystone Rare Coins paid me almost $375 more on my gold jewelry than the top buyer when I shopped around! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Prices Around!!! 2/2/2012

I have sold my gold jewelry on two separate occasions to Keystone Rare Coins now. The first time, I shopped around at local stores for the best prices on my items but found that Keystone beat out everyone by a few hundred dollars! This time when I went to sell, I went directly to Keystone Rare Coins! I will always go there to sell any of my jewelry because of their prices and service. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best in town by FAR!!! 1/16/2012

Both me and my wife have sold items to Keystone Rare Coins on numerous occasions. I had an old coin collection that I took to 4 other coin and jewelry stores and received far more from Keystone!! My wife also shopped around her yellow gold jewelry that she no longer wears and received $528 more than her highest offer from other buyers. Keystone definitely gives the highest prices and there employees are very nice and knowledgeable. I would recommend them with 5 stars any day!! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Gold and Silver Buyers Around! Great Prices!!! 10/17/2011

I have sold my gold and silver before, and Keystone pays the best prices by far! They made me feel very comfortable with my sale, and also seemed very knowledgable about the merchandise they were dealing with. I sold some coins along with my jewelry, and the gentleman gave me a great price. I walked out more satisfied with my sale than past experiences. Great business and people to deal with! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best gold and silver buyers 5/1/2011

I have been to many of the Lehigh Valley gold and silver buyers,and by far Keystone Rare coins give the BEST prices!I recently had a 14k gold watch,that was 9 dwt.I went to 3 different places in the Lehigh Valley,the ones that advertize the most,and was offered at Keystone,a lot more then the previous places offered me.I'm talking 70.00 more!!!They also bought some silver items I had,that I had taken to other places and they gave me more for that too!!They are by far the best buyers of gold and silver in the valley!!Highly recommended!!!The rest are rip-off artist!!!! more
Reply | Report abuse |

CROOKS - AWFUL PLACE TO DEAL WITH 4/29/2011

These people are scum-bags. If you are looking to get ripped off go deal with Fat-Buddy at Keystone. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Fantastic! 4/17/2011

Very friendly people, great service. I DID MY RESEARCH FIRST! I turned in old sterling flatware that no one wanted and the guys came extremely close to the figure I researched. So I trust them. I will return again. The store is not fancy. To me thats another clue that they can be trusted, they are not ""showey"" people. They readily answered my questions, and did not try to rush me out. Everything was weighed and calculated in front of me and explained thoroughly. Good people, good store. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Honest and Fair Pricing 3/5/2011

My mom had some sterling flatware to sell that she hasn't used in years. I have visited two places in the Lehigh Valley who buy silver. I chose Keystone Coin to sell it to. My first visit to them was for a quote. They were professional and courteous even though I did not sell it to them at that time. I returned to the shop a few days later with my mother who is 80 yrs young. The shop owner adjusted the three day old rate and gave us a very fair price. This price was the best of the two other competitors who advertised in the newspaper this week. My mom was very happy and I'm happy that she is happy. Thank you Keystone Coin. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Recommended for Gold and Silver Sales 5/18/2010

A few years ago, I was ripped off by Apple & Eve Antiques who paid less than fair market prices and even stole something that belonged to my late grandfather. I clearly would not deal with them again, so I researched dealers online. Keystone had great reviews so I called them. Pros: Fast service, fair prices Cons: Store is a bit messy and dirty more
Reply | Report abuse |

Fantastic Cutomer Service 2/12/2010

I took my old collection to a few establishments in the area and received the best pricing at Keystone. The people are friendly and the prices are right. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Dirty, rude and just cheap 11/3/2009

I went there to sell items of mine they were treating me like a I was an idiot. They had the same item available to sale for 3 x what they offered me for it. Talk about a rip off. Don't believe them in what they advertise for their prices. There prices are low. Cons: Place is dark and dingy. The workers are rude and mean more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great service! 10/18/2009

Very friendly, excellent service, and the best rates in town. Check them out for yourself, no reason to go anywhere else! Pros: Fair & knowledgeable! Cons: None! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Highly Recommend 10/4/2009

Great service. I took my gold jewelry to several dealers in the Lehigh Valley and was offered between $400 to 425. Keystone paid $600. Very nice staff. I had a great experience with this business and highly recommend it. Pros: Best prices for gold more
Reply | Report abuse |

Recommend Highly 10/2/2009

I don't know about coins or other things they buy, but they pay the highest rates in the valley for gold and platinum. I've called and/or visited most places in the valley who buy your ""old, unwanted"" jewelry, and I've consistently been paid the highest rates from KeyStone. Was paid $48 per dwt for platinum today when another person who claims to pay the highest rates in the valley would only pay me $30. That's a huge difference and resulted in me getting more than $200 more by going to KeyStone. Don't take my word for it...call or check around and you'll see they pay the highest rates. Friendly staff, too. Check it out! more
Reply | Report abuse |

LESS THAN PLEASED 3/30/2009

Without saying anything too ugly, I will just leave it at the simple fact that I am very, very sorry I sold them coins during one of thier hotels visits to my area. more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Owner Message

  • Keystone Rare Coins Are Large Wholesalers Of U.S. Coins, Currency, And Precious Metals Located In Allentown, Pennsylvania Serving The United States! Buying Buying Buying ! Gold, Platinum, And Sterling Jewelry, U.S. Gold, Platinum, And Silver Coins Large And Small Size Currency, Fine And Sterling Silver Industrial Gold And Platinum, Foreign Gold And Silver Coins. Also Specialized In Tiffany, Handel, And Pairpoint Lamps, Lionel Trains, Slot Machines, Old German Steins And More!

Additional information
  • Hours: monday: 09:00-17:00, tuesday: 09:00-17:00, wednesday: 09:00-17:00, thursday: 09:00-17:00, friday: 09:00-17:00, saturday: 09:00-14:00
badge