Jersey's is a pretty popular local fav. Their pizza and calzones are very good and the prices are not too bad. The service there can be attrocious at times - especially at lunch. The bartender there is very nice but some of the other staff seem less friendly. Speaking of the bartender - pretty good selection of beer on tap. The parking there is shared with the other local merchants, so it can be hit-or-miss - thursdays tend to be a miss (due to Market Night).
Pros: good pizza and calzones, good selection of beer, easy going atmosphere
Cons: service is bad at times, parking depends on other things happening downtown
more