We've been to El Pescador a couple of times. The restaurant itself is uninspiring (think old Denny's furniture), but the view overlooking Homer Harbor is fantastic. The food is consistently good - mexican / seafood mix - always fresh, good portions, and very tasty. It's not at the very top of the list if you are only in Homer for a few days, but if you find yourself looking for something other than "the top three" it's definitely worth a meal.
more