top 10

Ye Olde Tollgate Steakhouse

Claim
marker

974 East Boston Post Road
Mamaroneck, NY 10543

marker
(914) 381-7233
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews
( 11 )
( 4 )
( 9 )
( 11 )
( 4 )

Best

Last night was the first night I have been there since the new management has taken over and I must say that the reputation of a Peter Lugers with out the 2 hour drive is well des...

Worst

Steak was very solid but not anywhere near spectacular i.e. worth the heavy price we paid for it. 2 people (entree, drinks) cost 185. Ridiculous.

Overpriced 8/4/2011

Steak was very solid but not anywhere near spectacular i.e. worth the heavy price we paid for it. 2 people (entree, drinks) cost 185. Ridiculous. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Tollgate Steakhouse 8/4/2011

Overall, it was merely decent. Nothing too bad or anything too good. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Tollgate Critique 8/4/2011

I'll pass next time. My steak wasn't cooked how I asked them. I politely asked if they could take it back and the servers were instantly rude and gave no apology. Didn't like it. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Restaurant Review 8/4/2011

I'm so torn on this place. One time I have been there, everything was honestly pretty good (service, food quality, etc.) And the other time it was close to dreadful. I hate inconsistency so I'm bringing it back to 2 stars with a chance to improve. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Boom 8/4/2011

Great steak. Really liked it a lot. Appetizers kind of stunk and the staff was not very prompt, but steak makes a lot of things fall by the way side haha. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Ye Olde Tollgate Steakhouse Review 8/3/2011

Yep, it's good is a quality description. I don't know why everyone else is complaining so much. I liked my dining experience here very much. Prices are definitely a little high, but still worth it for delicious steak. Go with the porterhouse, trust me! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Haha 8/3/2011

Haha. Forget this place. Best thing about it was the waiting staff. Crab appetizer was so bland with little taste. Lamb entree was chewy and covered in fat with little real meat. Prices were more expensive than Charlie Sheen's drug habits. Pass. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Ughh 8/3/2011

Never coming back here again. They charge insane prices for food that is barely edible. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Just read the review and not the headline 8/3/2011

I agree with a lot of the previous reviews. This place is decent. Nothing is really amazing. more
Reply | Report abuse |

I would return 8/3/2011

I would return to this place. Really like my appetizer and my main order was really pretty good. The service was very nice. The decor of this place isn't anything special though and the prices are through the roof. At the end of the day, I would come back. more
Reply | Report abuse |

I think i'll pass next time 8/3/2011

I think I'll pass next time. Food was really unspectacular. I might have been able to cook something more flavorful myself. Prices are too expensive for merely mediocre food. I was disappointed, ovverall. more
Reply | Report abuse |

3 Stars 8/3/2011

This place is pretty decent. I got the crab appetizer which wasn't bad, but okay. Main dish was about the same. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Decent 8/3/2011

Pretty Decent. Not great though. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Skip it 8/3/2011

Nothing special. Prices are too steep. Food is only decent. Skip it if you've got another option. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Not for me 8/3/2011

Not living up to the hype. Waiters were very rude. Appetizers were plain and unappealing. Main course was barely better. Prices were waaaayyyyy too high. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Pretty Darn Good 8/3/2011

I really have nothing bad to say about this place other than the prices. The service was solid. Food was decent. I like this place and will be returning sometime in the future. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Not Bad 8/3/2011

Pretty good overall. Aside from the prices, I didn't have any major complaints. Go with the lamb, pretty good and juicy. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Ehh 8/3/2011

Ehh, not bad. Not very good either. Appetizers were dreadful but the main course (I got fish) was pretty decent. Waiting staff was kind of rude when I asked them to hold something on the fish dish. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Yep, It's Good 8/3/2011

3 stars is the perfect grade for this restaurant. Everything was very solid. Nothing blew me away. The waiting staff was very prompt and attentive and I enjoyed my meal. Prices could be a bit more lower, however. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Will not be returning 8/3/2011

Wow. This place didn't do it for me at all. The appetizers were bland and boring. The entrees were awful and they were unwilling to prepare it in a slightly different way after I asked. The meals were severely expensive as well. more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 Next >
Menu for Ye Olde Tollgate Steakhouse


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Editorial

  • Westchester steakhouse with lunch specials, appetizers, extra large T-bones and surf and turf on the menu.

  • 11/15/2005 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: Sat: 5pm-10:30pm, Sun: 4pm-9pm, Mon-Thu: 12pm-3pm, 5pm-9:30pm, Fri: 12pm-3pm, 5pm-10:30pm
  • Payments: Visa, Discover, Master Card, American Express
badge