Scarlatto

I recently had a corporate event at Scarlatto's in early Dec. We had 30 people and were assigned to the 2nd floor, which we had to ourselves. The room up there is narrow and can easily accommodate that number of guests. The room is decorated very nicely and the temperature is climate controlled so it was very comfortable. Of course, I wouldn't have wanted to knock over a glass because there might have been a domino affect down the long narrow table... ; P Pros: Great food, prices and service Cons: Could be affected by theater crowds but I didn't witness that when I was there. more

I'm glad this isn't as popular as it should, because i would hate to see them jack their prices and their quality go down. You're getting homemade italian food at such reasonable prices, that i feel bad for people that goes to the olive garden, which is overpriced fast food italian up the block. more

Upon walking into scarlatto I knew I would be in for a great ride. The pre-theater menu offers a wonderful selection of food AND ALL FOR OUTRAGEOUSLY CHEAP PRICE!!! the Waitress was incredibly sweet...giving great service even though she was busy with so many other tables during the theater rush. she recommended the delicious seafood salad which is definetly worth a try. and the branzino was just outrageous. me and my wife were extremely satisfied with the reccomendations...our compliments to the chef! more

This place is fabulous!!! We were in NY for a weekend in late February and while walking by, it caught our eye. We went there the next night and had some of the best Italian food ever!!! The panacotta with strawberries is to die for. Just so silky and smooth. Their service was very good and the ambience great. We were so happy to have found such a gem in midtown that we went back for lunch just before our flight back to SF. What a great value as well. Three course meal for lunch was $13, the prices for dinner were just as great! Pros: Great food, Great service, In Midtown more

You can't find food at this level in midtown for these prices. I was very pleasantly surprised. The food is good, solid gourmet italian fare and the service was excellent. The waiters were quite attentive and made good wine suggestions. more

My boyfriend and I went there on our anniversay. We went there to enjoy our dinner but we came out furious. First, they took over 10 minutes to bring over every drinks we ordered-water, coke, martini. Then, the food we ordered were nasty. We had chicken, which had no seasoning at all, thrown on top of salad. And fettuccini with wild mushrooms just tasted like linguini in mixture of ketchup and chilli. Mash potatoes were the best food they had. Then, they forget our glass of wine that we ordered, and charge us when we receive our check. And she accuse us of putting away the wine glass went when she herself has removed it to another table when we first ordered because only one of us ordered wine. This was the worst restaurant I've ever been to. Don't EVER go to this place. You'll regret it. Cons: Service, Food, Waitress/Waiters more

I love the food here! The pre-theater pre-fix meal is the best. Had prosciutto, tomato, and mozarella to start. Veal as main course... and topped it off with tiramisu... the food here was so good... and all under $30.00. Which is even better. The only bad thing about this place is the service is kinda slow... waiter were unattentive... but the other staff were... which is as equally good... will definitely come back here Pros: Food, Price Cons: Slow servie more