JavaScript is not enabled.
Rusty Anchor Restaurant - 4 Reviews - 5510 3rd Ave, Key West, FL - Seafood Restaurants Reviews - Phone (305) 292-4151

Rusty Anchor Restaurant

Claim
marker
5510 3rd Ave
Key West, FL 33040
marker
(305) 292-4151
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

Rusty Anchor Restaurant - Key West, FL
Rusty Anchor Restaurant - Key West, FL
Rusty Anchor Restaurant - Key West, FL
Rusty Anchor Restaurant - Key West, FL
Rusty Anchor Restaurant - Key West, FL

Reviews

( 3 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )

Best

While in Key West, we located this restaurant by a phone application, and decided to give it a shot. Finding it could have been easier, and we ended up on the back side of the bui...

Worst

All reviews seem positive

Nice and Relaxed 5/6/2012

While in Key West, we located this restaurant by a phone application, and decided to give it a shot. Finding it could have been easier, and we ended up on the back side of the building to enter. It looked at first as though we were going to have to walk through a cooler, but this wasn't the case. The dining area and front side of the restaurant are very clean and nautically themed. The waitress that we had kept us full on tea by leaving us a pitcher, which was just what we wanted. I had the stone crab claws, which we excellent and just what I had been craving. The Captain's Platter can feed two with ease, and the Key Lime Pie (that is made on Marathon) is delightful. We all felt like our server made the dinner even better than it could have been, and this has been our favorite restaurant. Prices are very reasonable, especially for the type of dining that you find in this area. more

great place 2/9/2012

this place has great food and their seafood is locally caught it is alittle hard to find but it is worht it ! great place!! more

here fishie fishie 1/21/2012

they had wonderful food at very reasonable prices. Use your GPS because its hard to find more

BEST SEAFOOD ! 1/7/2012

Was in there one night for clam strips and it was fabulous ! they have the freshest seafood because they catch all there own seafood and the resturant is so beautiful on the inside . the service was outstanding and i will definately return again and spread a good word,thanks again RUSTY ANCHOR ! more
< Previous 1 Next >
SUMMER SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 9/30/2018

Fresh Seafood, Drinks, and More

Owner Message

  • The Rusty Anchor Seafood Restaurant is one of Key West s best kept secrets. Just 1 mile north of Key West, nestled in a quiet neighborhood off US 1 on Stock Island, it has been owned and operated by a local family since 1983. It offers the freshest local seafood that comes straight from the commercial fishing fleet to its fish market and restaurant. The Rusty Anchor has been a local and tourist favorite for years, featuring unbelievable conch fritters, fresh shrimp, and a selection of local fish that is prepared to the customer s liking. Prices and portions are always agreeable to the customer looking for great seafood at an affordable price. The Rusty Anchor is open for lunch and dinner and offers a full bar with a wide selection of tropical drinks, including Patty s famous rum punch. The Rusty Anchor accommodates many small and large parties in its main dining room and has a beautiful adjoining room with an outdoor garden for private parties. Come join Ramon and Patty Rodriquez and family for an unforgettable dining experience and share the local s best kept secret since 1983.. Lunch Specials,Dinner Specials,Take-out,Happy hour Specials,Fresh Fish Daily,Fresh Fish Market

Additional information

  • Hours:

    24 Hour Emergency Service Available
  • Payments:

    American Express, Discover, Master Card, Visa
  • Neighborhoods:

    Key West
badge