Oh man, there's no contest. When I want a good, thick local slice of prime pie, I head straight to Rudy's. It's usually on my downtown route after passing Hasting's, and they always have the best hot pepperoni pies waiting to enter my mouth. They have really good ice, and I usually purchase an ENORMOUS Coke and chug it down along with my scrumptious pizza pie. I do get a little flustered when I finally finish my Coke and refills are not free. That's ok, they are only 5 cents, but I wish they were free. It's a small price to pay for the best pepperoni pizza in town. I think I'll go there right now.