JavaScript is not enabled.
Puleo's Too - 9 Reviews - 259 W 45TH St, New York, NY - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (212) 768-9232

Puleo's Too

Claim
marker
259 W 45TH St
New York, NY 10036
marker
(212) 768-9232
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews

( 6 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 1 )

Best

I've taken friends, family, and even dates to this little spot frequently, and have never had a bad meal. The wait staff is very aware of getting you out on time for the theatre,...

Worst

Other than a good location I can't think of any other reason to dine here. We were a party of 7 people and two had to send their dinner back. The veal was like shoe leather and ...

Never a bad meal! 1/25/2007

I've taken friends, family, and even dates to this little spot frequently, and have never had a bad meal. The wait staff is very aware of getting you out on time for the theatre, which is a plus! It's relatively small, so it's not like you'll get lost in a crowd and never find your waiter. :) Sometimes the food is rushed, yes, but that's due to people making reservations too close to the start time of a show. Make a reservation at 6 to ensure plenty of schmooze time before rushing out. Prices are actually reasonable for the usually overpriced theater district. Try the lobster bisque - YUM! Pros: Great food, good value, kind staff, quick to get you out to your B'way show! Cons: Sometimes other patrons too loud (B&T) more

Don't waste your money 6/1/2006

Other than a good location I can't think of any other reason to dine here. We were a party of 7 people and two had to send their dinner back. The veal was like shoe leather and the salmon had no taste. I had been there a few times going back a year or two. Something has for sure changed... and not for the better. Our waiter had a bad attitude and should not work with the public. Pros: took reservation, location Cons: food, service more

Very Disappointing 4/9/2006

The food was almost tasteless and the service was very poor. Entrees were served before the appetizer was finished. The calamari was undercooked and tough. The special of shrimp and sole had no taste at all. The bread was a below average white bread, not a nice crusty Italian that I would have expected and the garlic infused oil had been salted to excess. The only thing positive to say is the restaurant is well located in the theatre district, but there are many, many far better Italian restaurants nearby - choose one of them Pros: location Cons: food, service more

Great Food Great location 9/22/2005

My friend in NY took me here for my birthday and I must say it was quite an ejoyable experience. The food was fabulous. It was a little pricy, but that's New York. The service was great the staff was VERY friendly. Then again my friend is a regular there, so she knows EVERYONE!! I have NO bad things to say about it except that they don't have free refills on Soda. Us folks in Washington are used to having free refills. Other than that it was GREAT!!! Pros: Great Food, Friendly Staff, Prompt Service Cons: No free refills more

Hidden Treasure of the Theatre District 11/8/2004

Almost a year ago, I stumbled upon Puleo's Too, a small and inviting Italian restaurant in the heart of Mid-town NYC, and not a week goes by that I do not have at least have one meal there. The food is prepared exquisitely. I have had almost every item on the menu and have not been dissapointed once! Puleo's makes you feel like home with their delicious meals and fast and curteous wait staff. The Rustic and original look of the restaurant just add the familiar ambience. If you are visiting New York, and have an oppurtunity, do not hesitate to try Puleo's Restaurants. They cater to all with a hearty appetite for excellent Italian food. And if you are watching a show, Puleo's thrives on pre-theatre rush and will have you sat, fed, and happy with time to spare for your show! A MANGIARE!!!! Pros: Inexpensive, Friendly, Excellent Martinis more

Theatre District Gem! 10/31/2004

Living in New York, I tend to think of restraunts in the Theatre District as serving small portions of mediocre overpriced food served by surly wanna-be actors. At Puleo's Too I couldn't have been more wrong. Healthy portions of great down home Italian food served by a friendly staff. Nice martinis also. Pros: Nice waiters, good food, quick service more

Great Food! 6/2/2004

This is the place to be when you want true great italian food! You cant go wrong with anything you order! Pros: great food, great service, nice layout more

Great experence 2/1/2004

The food and service are excellent. The waiters are aware that you have a show to catch and do a very good job without making you breathless. A wide range of choices and all the food is excellently prepared. We would go back agin. Pros: Good food, Good service more

An Orgasmic Experience!!! 7/23/2003

The atmosphere was extremely enjoyable and the waiters were great. I would definetly go back just to see the waiters! In addition, the food was exceptional and the waiters even gave us a fine tour of the city! It was truly a memorable experience!!! Pros: Prime Location, Exceptional Service, Fun Ambiance more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Puleo's Too




SUMMER SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 9/30/2018

Additional information

  • Neighborhoods:

    Midtown, Theater District - Times Square
badge