Paddy Cake Bakery

Claim
marker

4763 Liberty Ave
Pittsburgh, PA 15224

marker
(412) 621-4477
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Reviews
( 8 )
( 0 )
( 3 )
( 1 )
( 7 )

Best

The donuts are out of this world. Fresh, filling and oh sooo good with a great selection.. They also have great canoli!!

Worst

Ordered our wedding cake from them and soon came to regret it. You have to wait forever (10-20 minutes!) on hold every time you phone in and then when someone does get on the lin...

RUINED WEDDING CAKE 1/14/2006

Rating: I ordered a cake for 120, 90 showed and we still didn't have enough cake. When we went to cut our cake, we got through icing then couldn't get the knife further. It was stuck on a piece of plastic that was on the whole top of each tier under the icing. When the hotel went to cut the cake, same problem. They had to lift a plastic support sheet off of the cake, which pulled off all of the icing and pulled apart most of the cake. The bakery claimed this is industry standard, but both the hotel and 2 other bakeries said that the support usually goes just under the tier, not over the top of it. Paddy-cake blamed the hotel stating that they pulled it off too fast. But, even if they pulled it off slow like they claim, it still would have pulled off all of the icing. I told the hotel that Paddy-cake blamed them and they called Paddy-cake themselves. Paddy-cake denied ever saying it. Paddy-cake refused to give me any sort of refund "since you were able to use some of the cake". We should have had 30 extra pieces and instead some of the guests (including the bride) didn't get any! Those who had some said that it tasted good, but what does that matter when not all the guests get some. Furthermore, the driver didn't leave a box for the top layer. I was told "he must have forgotten". The hotel had to empty fudge out of a box that it came in and put my top layer in that. What a disaster. I'll never go there again and I recommend that no one else let them ruin their cake either! more

RUINED WEDDING CAKE 1/14/2006

I ordered a cake for 120, 90 showed and we still didn't have enough cake. When we went to cut our cake, we got through icing then couldn't get the knife further. It was stuck on a piece of plastic that was on the whole top of each tier under the icing. When the hotel went to cut the cake, same problem. They had to lift a plastic support sheet off of the cake, which pulled off all of the icing and pulled apart most of the cake. The bakery claimed this is industry standard, but both the hotel and 2 other bakeries said that the support usually goes just under the tier, not over the top of it. Paddy-cake blamed the hotel stating that they pulled it off too fast. But, even if they pulled it off slow like they claim, it still would have pulled off all of the icing. I told the hotel that Paddy-cake blamed them and they called Paddy-cake themselves. Paddy-cake denied ever saying it. Paddy-cake refused to give me any sort of refund "since you were able to use some of the cake". We should have had 30 extra pieces and instead some of the guests (including the bride) didn't get any! Those who had some said that it tasted good, but what does that matter when not all the guests get some. Furthermore, the driver didn't leave a box for the top layer. I was told "he must have forgotten". The hotel had to empty fudge out of a box that it came in and put my top layer in that. What a disaster. I'll never go there again and I recommend that no one else let them ruin their cake either! more
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Paddy Cake Bakery


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Editorial
  • The Skinny
    Paddy Cake is like most bakeries. Walk in, take a number and start staring at all the treats that taste so good. The bakery surrounds the waiting area on three sides with...

  • 8/18/2003 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Payments: Master Card, Visa, Cash
  • Neighborhoods: Bloomfield
badge