All reviews seem negative
Why doesn't Key West have a single good Mexican food restaurant? This is as close as you can get but still not as good as a cheap burrito stand in Texas.
This isn't Tex-Mex, we like to call it Fresh Mex. It's a style of Mexican food that's layered, sophisticated in flavor, and completely original. We use all fresh ingredients, local wherever possible and make everything from scratch. We even roast our own chilies. Old Town Mexican Cafe southwest dishes have garnered numerous awards including Chef of the Year (2003, Key West Restaurant Association), Best Entree (2008, Key West Master Chefs Classic), and a People's Choice Award (2009, Key West Master Chefs Classic).