JavaScript is not enabled.
Michael Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - 5 Reviews - 475 New Haven Ave, Milford, CT - Pizza Restaurants Reviews - Phone (203) 877-1370
top 10

Michael Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

Claim
marker
475 New Haven Ave
Milford, CT 06460
marker
(203) 877-1370
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

Michael Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Milford, CT
Michael Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Milford, CT
Michael Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Milford, CT
Michael Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Milford, CT
Michael Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Milford, CT

Reviews

( 2 )
( 1 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

The best thin crust pizza and prices are very reasonable. Anything I have ever ordered has been great, from the subs to their catering menu-- I have never had a bad meal.

Worst

have been here several times, as well as ordering pizza delivery. Tonight we were very disappointed. they do not have fish on the menu, so we asked, after checking with the chef,...

Rip off! 10/18/2016

have been here several times, as well as ordering pizza delivery. Tonight we were very disappointed. they do not have fish on the menu, so we asked, after checking with the chef, we were told they had salmon with a cream sauce, but after asking if I could have it without the sauce, or at least on the side, I was told they check said "it wouldn't look good without the sauce. REALLY! Have never heard of such a thing. My husband ordered it, but tried not to eat most of the cream sauce, which actually overpowered the dish. We never asked the price of this "special" and were really surprised when the check arrived. It was $33.00, granted it come with ravioli, which we think was lobster, ( very sparse ). But for a restaurant of this caliber, the price was ridiculous. Unfortunately, we will not return here and will not recommend it to friends, all of us who dine out quite a bit. more

Great Place 11/3/2009

The best thin crust pizza and prices are very reasonable. Anything I have ever ordered has been great, from the subs to their catering menu-- I have never had a bad meal. more

It Could Be Better! 11/5/2008

I will admit Michael Anthony's makes a tasty pizza, but wow do they ever cut costs! He rarely spreads the cheest to the edge of the pie, meaning you get 3 to 4 inches of nothing but sauce for a topping. Beware of requesting toppings like bacon (it is not crispy so unless you like what amounts to warmed limp pork fat skip it) and onions (he rough chops them so big you get a huge mouthful of onion and not a blend of flavors). Also the front of his store is gross & needs a cleaning. more

No image

Good New Haven style pizza in Milford 9/24/2006

If you are craving New Haven style pizza but don't want to leave the town of Milford, why not try Michael Anthony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant. They are on New Haven Avenue in Milford and offer free local delivery. They feature pizzas in sizes small to an extra large eighteen inch pie. They also serve sicilian style pizzas, stuffed breads, hot and cold sub sandwiches, and traditional Italian dinners. They also have a catering menu offering selections for crowds as small as eight to as large as twenty. more

No image

Great pizza and subs! 3/24/2006

There are a lot of pizza restaurants around town, but we always use Michael Anthony's. The pizza is great, with a delicious sauce and a thin crust, and the subs are so big and so filling that most people could never finish the entire thing in one sitting. The staff is also very pleasant and your food will always be ready on time. more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Michael Anthony's Pizza & Pasta




SUMMER SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 9/30/2018

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon. - Thu. 11am - 9:30pm;Fri. - Sat. 11am - 10pm;Sun. 1pm - 9pm
  • Payments:

    American Express, Master Card, Visa, Discover
  • Neighborhoods:

    Woodsmont
badge