I first went to Rotee just after they opened and have been back almost every week since. they have consistently great food at great prices. I love it. My favorites: chicken tikka masala, chicken or lamb karahi, chicken tikka boti, onion naan, and the free chai.
I get the feeling that some of the bad reviews on this site may be written by jealous people associated with other Pakistani/Indian restaurants. Try it for yourself. I bet you'll love it!