JavaScript is not enabled.
La Casita - 12 Reviews - 1355 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH - Family Restaurants Reviews - Phone (614) 457-0823

La Casita

Claim
marker
1355 Bethel Rd
Columbus, OH 43220
marker
(614) 457-0823
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Reviews

( 9 )
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

I have been to La Casita many times with never a miss. Tonight I tried a Torta (Al Pastor pork) for the first time and it was simply amazing. The cilantro was super fresh, a nic...

Worst

La Casita was great for many years... so much that I would drive across town to dine there. The food has consistently been bad during my past three experiences. Not sure why, ...

Best full service Mexican in Columbus 12/6/2011

I have been to La Casita many times with never a miss. Tonight I tried a Torta (Al Pastor pork) for the first time and it was simply amazing. The cilantro was super fresh, a nice crispy bread (roll?), and the Al Pastor pork was so good that I scrounged every crumb. Wow! Out the door including a margarita, for $10. more

Always enjoyable 9/28/2011

I'm a vegetarian so there isn't a huge selection available however their veggie burrito is great (and as far as I can tell, it's vegan as well. There is no cheese and toppings are on the side.) The service is always fast and friendly. They have a great patio. You can easily tell from the outside this used to be a Long John Silver's but don't pass this by thinking it's fly by night fast food joint. I also like their chips and salsa and margaritas. more

Incredible fish tacos 7/26/2011

My husband and I have been curious about this place (a former Long John Silvers) and finally went last weekend. Their grilled fish tacos were the best in the city. They were spectacular! So moist and flavorful! What a fabulous surprise - we will definitely go back. We each had a combo plate with black beans and rice - it was all good. The furniture is colorful and bright. We definitely recommend it. more

Best ! 5/14/2011

I love this place! My uncle is the owner & my whole family works there. They have alot of business and has come a long way! The food & drinks plus desserts are amazing, it's well worth it. Bring friends & family and enjoy! more

best mexican in columbus 4/19/2011

i love mexican food, i lived in the southwest for many years and when people in the midwest say lets go get mexican food i usualy say no thnk you. however this place is really authentic, i been going here for years. the salsa is great just as it should be, the food is very authentic i recomend the fish tacos, or any tacos for that matter. they have a bar so you can get margaritas and other drinks the staff is very friendly. just as mexican food should be it is very affordable, try this place out you will not be sorry. more

I used to love this place,,, 5/2/2010

La Casita was great for many years... so much that I would drive across town to dine there. The food has consistently been bad during my past three experiences. Not sure why, but it is not as good. Haven't seen the owner for a while, either. I really hope they bounce back, but they are no longer top of my list for Mexican food. Pros: Service Cons: Food has gone downhill more

Always Delicious!!! 12/18/2009

We have enjoyed every meal we have gotten there. The margaritas are strong and delicious. I always order the ceviche to eat with my chips. Pros: fantastic food, ample portions, friendly service Cons: small and can get crowded more

Small in space, big in character 5/3/2007

While a former Long John Silver building may not be the best place for Mexican, La Casita is as good as you could expect. The crowd is a good mix of college students, young couples, and familes. The service is always friendly. The only problem is it is getting too popular now. Expect a wait Friday nights. more

User review by lori908 3/24/2006

Fabulous food. Now my favorite restaurant. Great service, good food, great authentic atmoshphere. Not too much room for seating if it's a busy Saturday night but I would go to eat there anytime! Their Carnitas is fabulous. Pros: Good Food, Great service Cons: Not enough tables more

muy bien 1/24/2006

This is my favorite Mexican restaurant! Great food, margaritas, service, everything. I eat there so often the owner actually greets me when I go in. I have to highly suggest the Barbacoa burrito. It's a lot to eat but it's great. When it's warm enough they also have a great little patio where you can eat. Pros: food, drinks, out side seating more

great 1/7/2005

we love this place. We eat whenever we can. The service is great.. The food is good. variety of drinks more

M E X I C O!! 4/11/2003

This place is the best. My favorite use to be Chile Verde in Columbus, which is very good. But this place has a unique taste that makes it stand out from all competitors. My girlfriend has never like Mexican till she tried La Casita. They didn't spend alot on the interior, but that just adds to its charm. more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for La Casita




FALL SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 12/30/2018

Editorial

  • Known for its authentic seafood and meat fajitas, the restaurant offers seafood cocktails and tortas at affordable prices.

  • 1/29/2007 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Payments:

    Discover, American Express, Visa, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods:

    Knolls West
badge