I had dinner with friends at Ilili the other nite and I was really looking forward to it based on the previous review. But I have to disagree with most of what the reviewer said about this place. True, the atmosphere is very inviting with the high ceilings and candle-light. It was perfect for meeting friends or a casual date. A funny thing about the restrooms..there are instructions on how to lock and unlock the doors! One of my friends got locked in and had to call us to get him out! One of the other restroom doors had broken glass that was all taped up and according to the waiter a guy had gotten stuck inside, didn't have his phone and had to kick his way out! A word to the wise..if you go to this place bring your phone to the restroom or just hold it! The service was fine, though the waiter did bring the wrong beer both times my friend ordered it! We had the hummus, babaghanoush and brussels sprouts as appetizers. The brussels sprouts were wonderful, roasted with grapes. The hummus and baba were bland and nothing special. I ordered the lamb chops and while the flavor was delicious, there were only about 4 bites of meat and nothing was served along with them. My companions had the shawarma which apparently tasted fine but was also tiny, and the lamb kebob which was completely over-salted. We shared the chocolate cake for dessert which was very good and the coffee and espresso were both excellent. However, after we paid our bill of nearly $200 (including drinks) we were all still hungry! I would not mind paying that much for dinner if I had come out at least satisfied. Unfortunately Ilili was a let-down and I would not go back unless they included side dishes or salads with their entrees. Not worth your time or money..there are hundreds of restaurants in NY that are much better!
Pros: Inviting atmosphere, close to subway, nice wine list
Cons: Tiny portions, inconsistent service, not worth the prices
more