This is our third year eating at the Grotto for New Years Eve, it can be a little pricey, for my hubby, myself and our 2 children ages 6 and 4 too eat with tip it was $250.00. The food is very flavorful, has great presentation and is well thought out. Last year the Grotto had a dance floor for NY and we missed it this year. The service is always very pleasent and chef Salerno always comes to each table for a meet and greet. Our family goes to the Grotto every couple of months and for most major holidays we always have a wonderful times and leave stuffed!
Pros: quaint, wonderful food, good service
Cons: a little pricey, seating can be cramped!